What Is The Best Everything But The Kitchen Sink Cookies [In 2025]

best everything but the kitchen sink cookies offer a deliciously complex flavor and texture experience for cookie lovers everywhere. These mixes combine a variety of mix-ins like chocolate chunks, oats, walnuts, coconut flakes, caramel bits, and mini pretzels to create a truly indulgent treat. Whether you want a quick bake or a gourmet-style cookie, these mixes deliver satisfying results with minimal effort.

For readers in the USA seeking convenient, flavorful cookie mixes, these options provide excellent variety and quality. Key factors include ingredient inclusions, texture balance, and ease of preparation. This guide will help you find the best everything but the kitchen sink cookies to suit your taste and baking needs.

Below is a quick comparison table to help you evaluate the top products, followed by detailed reviews and buying advice.

Quick Comparison: best everything but the kitchen sink cookies

Our Top 5 best everything but the kitchen sink cookies

We selected five models for different needs and budgets, prioritizing feature quality, performance, fit/compatibility, reliability, and value.

Trader Joe’s Everything but the Kitchen Sink Cookie Mix

Overview

This mix suits bakers who want a rich, complex cookie with minimal prep. It features 43% mix-ins including chocolate chunks, oats, walnuts, coconut flakes, caramel bits, and mini pretzels. The cookies bake to crispy edges with a chewy center and melty chocolate throughout.

Ideal for those seeking upscale bakery flavor at home without the high price. Available in the USA with kosher dairy certification.

Specs

→ 15 ounces (425 grams) mix weight
→ 43% mix-ins by volume
→ Includes chocolate, oats, walnuts, coconut flakes
→ Requires butter and egg to prepare
→ Kosher (dairy)-certified

Pros

👍 Limited time item from Trader Joe’s
👍 High mix-in content for flavor
👍 Crispy edges and chewy center
👍 Melty chocolate and caramel bits
👍 Kosher (dairy)-certified

Cons

👎 Limited availability
👎 Requires additional ingredients
👎 May not suit nut allergies

Customer Experience

Customers appreciate the easy assembly and bakery-quality taste. The texture balance and flavor complexity stand out during daily use.

Best For

Upscale bakery flavor lovers

Check Today’s Price

Trader J’s Everything but the Kitchen Sink Cookie Mix, Limited Edition, 15oz/425g (Pack of 1)

Overview

This limited edition cookie mix is perfect for those wanting a single pack with the classic everything but the kitchen sink flavor. It offers the same variety of mix-ins in a convenient size.

Great for occasional bakers or gift buyers in the USA looking for a special treat.

Specs

→ 15 ounces (425 grams) mix weight
→ Limited Edition release
→ Pack of 1
→ Includes multiple mix-ins
→ Requires butter and egg to prepare

Pros

👍 Everything but the Kitchen Sink Cookie Mix
👍 Limited Edition packaging
👍 Convenient single pack
👍 Easy to bake
👍 Good for gifting

Cons

👎 Limited availability
👎 No detailed ingredient list
👎 Requires additional ingredients

Customer Experience

Users find this mix straightforward to prepare with consistent flavor. The limited edition status adds appeal for collectors.

Best For

Limited edition collectors

Check Today’s Price

2-Pack Everything but the Kitchen Sink Cookie Mix, Limited Edition, 15oz/425g

Overview

This value pack includes two limited edition mixes, ideal for frequent bakers or sharing. It maintains the classic everything but the kitchen sink flavor profile with diverse mix-ins.

Suitable for USA customers wanting convenience and quantity.

Specs

→ 15 ounces (425 grams) per pack
→ Limited Edition release
→ Pack of 2
→ Includes multiple mix-ins
→ Requires butter and egg to prepare

Pros

👍 Everything but the Kitchen Sink Cookie Mix
👍 Limited Edition packaging
👍 Pack of 2 for value
👍 Easy to bake
👍 Good for sharing

Cons

👎 Limited availability
👎 Requires additional ingredients
👎 No detailed ingredient list

Customer Experience

Buyers appreciate the quantity and consistent flavor. The pack suits households baking regularly.

Best For

Value pack buyers

Check Today’s Price

Trader J’s Everything but the Kitchen Sink Cookie Mix, Limited Edition, 15oz/425g (Pack of 1)

Overview

This single pack limited edition mix is similar to other Trader J’s offerings, featuring the classic mix-ins and easy preparation. It suits those wanting a single batch of rich cookies.

Available in the USA with limited stock.

Specs

→ 15 ounces (425 grams) mix weight
→ Limited Edition release
→ Pack of 1
→ Includes multiple mix-ins
→ Requires butter and egg to prepare

Pros

👍 Everything but the Kitchen Sink Cookie Mix
👍 Limited Edition packaging
👍 Convenient single pack
👍 Easy to bake
👍 Good for gifting

Cons

👎 Limited availability
👎 Requires additional ingredients
👎 No detailed ingredient list

Customer Experience

Users find it easy to prepare with consistent flavor and texture. The limited edition status adds a special touch.

Best For

Limited availability seekers

Check Today’s Price

Buying Guide: best everything but the kitchen sink cookies

Consider Mix-In Variety

The hallmark of the best everything but the kitchen sink cookies is a diverse mix of ingredients. Look for mixes with chocolate chunks, nuts, oats, caramel bits, and pretzels for a complex flavor and texture.

Texture Preferences

Decide if you prefer cookies with crispy edges and chewy centers or a more uniform texture. Many mixes aim for a balance, but some may lean more toward one texture.

Ease of Preparation

Check if the mix requires additional ingredients like butter and eggs. Some mixes are more straightforward, while others need more prep but yield richer results.

Availability and Packaging

Limited edition mixes may offer unique flavors but can be harder to find. Consider pack size and whether you want a single batch or multiple packs for value.

Dietary Certifications

If dietary restrictions matter, look for certifications such as kosher or allergen information. This ensures the product fits your needs without surprises.

FAQs: best everything but the kitchen sink cookies

What makes these cookies “everything but the kitchen sink”?

They include a wide variety of mix-ins like chocolate, nuts, oats, and pretzels, creating a complex flavor and texture.

Do these mixes require extra ingredients?

Yes, most require butter and eggs to complete the cookie dough before baking.

Are these cookie mixes suitable for people with nut allergies?

No, many mixes contain nuts like walnuts, so they are not recommended for those with nut allergies.

Can I find these mixes outside the USA?

Availability may be limited outside the USA, especially for limited edition releases.

How long do these cookie mixes last?

Typically, they have a shelf life of several months when stored in a cool, dry place.

Are these cookies crunchy or chewy?

They usually have crispy outer edges with a chewy center for a balanced texture.

Is there a difference between regular and limited edition mixes?

Limited edition mixes may have special packaging or availability but generally contain similar mix-ins.

Final Verdict: best everything but the kitchen sink cookies

For the richest flavor and texture, Trader Joe’s Everything but the Kitchen Sink Cookie Mix is the top pick. Limited edition packs offer good value and variety for collectors or frequent bakers.